I grew up with Drake’s Cakes – Yankee Doodles, Coffee Cake, Devil Dogs and Ring Dings. They were my childhood favorites and I loved seeing that happy duck logo.
They’re all still available and sometimes I give in to my urge for comfort food. But there’s one that I miss – Drake’s Oatmeal Cookies. I’ve searched all over but it seems that they don’t make those any more.
They used to come three to a cellophane wrapped package. They were classic cookies, not chewy but crisp and crumbly, also cheap and perfect for a snack. There was nothing like them dunked in coffee for breakfast. I’d given up on ever tasting them again until our neighbor Susan brought over some cookies she’s made. There was a variety and I noticed a few oatmeal cookies that looked familiar. Well, they looked like Drake’s, crumbled like Drake’s and they tasted like Drake’s. Susan, being from Baltimore never heard of Drake’s Oatmeal Cookies, a New York phenomena, and didn’t know why I got so excited.
1896 – Newman Drake opened the N.E. Drake Baking Company on 135th Street in Harlem in New York City.
I’m not a baker but I got her recipe and made them. Even if you’ve never had a Drake’s Oatmeal Cookie you should try these.
Susan’s Oatmeal Cookie Recipe that tastes like Drake’s
A lot of ingredients for a little cookie but worth it.
In Bowl #1 – Mix the flour, salt, cinnamon, baking powder and baking soda.
In Bowl #2 – mix the milk, vanilla, and eggs.
In Bowl #3 – or in an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, mix the butter with the brown and white sugar, and beat on medium speed until light and fluffy. Reduce speed to low, gradually add milk mixture, and beat well. Add the flour mixture, and beat until just combined.
Remove bowl from the electric mixer, and stir in the (rolled) oats. Place the dough in the refrigerator at least 2 hours or overnight.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees and let the dough come to room temperature. Shape 2 tablespoons of dough into a ball; place on the cookie sheet. Press it with the bottom of a measuring cup or glass to flatten dough into rounds.
Bake until light brown (14 to16 minutes) rotating the sheet halfway through. Allow them to cool and become crisp before serving.
Thank you so much for this recipe. I was addicted to these cookies when I was a kid. They were $.10 a pack with 6 cookies per pack back in 1962-3 if I remember the dates correctly.
Lower East Side in Manhattan.
If they don’t make them anymore it is a shame. I’ll definitely give this recipe a try. Thank you again.
I’d given up on ever tasting them again until our neighbor Susan brought over some cookies she’s made. There was a variety and I noticed a few oatmeal cookies that looked familiar. Well, they looked like Drake’s, crumbled like Drake’s and they tasted like Drake’s. Susan, being from Baltimore never heard of Drake’s Oatmeal Cookies, a New York phenomena, and didn’t know why I got so excited.
Thank you so much for this recipe. I was addicted to these cookies when I was a kid. They were $.10 a pack with 6 cookies per pack back in 1962-3 if I remember the dates correctly.
Lower East Side in Manhattan.
If they don’t make them anymore it is a shame. I’ll definitely give this recipe a try. Thank you again.
I remember them from about that time. They were my addiction too.
I would like to get the drakes oatmeal cookie recipes. I missed them
I hope you enjoy them.